Roster Decisions 2026: Cincinnati Reds
By Peyton Hayes ·
Cincinnati did most of its option work before the World Series parade in Milwaukee was over. The Reds went 75-87, finished last in the NL Central, and lost Hunter Greene to his second Tommy John surgery in August, so this was always going to be a winter of clearing space and deciding who is worth paying. This is a look back at what the Reds did through the Nov. 2 deadline, why, and what it cost, followed by what is still open: Rule 5 protection on Nov. 17 and the non-tender deadline on Nov. 20.
What Cincinnati Did
Tyler Stephenson, Brady Singer and Brock Burke became free agents on Oct. 29, the day after the World Series ended. Left-hander Brandon Leibrandt, who had been outrighted earlier, elected free agency the same day. Neither Stephenson nor Singer got the $23.15 million qualifying offer, so the Reds get no draft pick if they sign elsewhere. For a club in this payroll range, that was the cost of not risking a $23.15 million yes.
On Oct. 31 the Reds declined their side of two mutual options. Eugenio Suárez's was $16 million with no buyout, and he hit .212 with 26 homers and a career-worst strikeout rate at 35. Pierce Johnson's was $8 million, and declining it cost a $1 million buyout after a 4.62 ERA. Earlier that afternoon Emilio Pagán turned down his $10 million player option. That one was the surprise, since he went 19-for-19 in save chances after coming off the injured list July 1, but he gets to test a market for closers at 35 instead of taking $10 million. None of the three cost Cincinnati more than Johnson's buyout. Every 2027 option on this roster has now been decided, and none was picked up. The rest belong to longer deals and aren't due for years.
Those moves left five openings on the 40-man, and on Nov. 2 the Reds used two of them on waiver claims: right-handers Duncan Davitt from San Francisco and Paxton Schultz from Washington. A claim costs a 40-man spot and the player's contract, and nothing else. Davitt had a 7.88 ERA in his debut season, and Schultz had a 6.40 ERA in 32 1/3 innings, so neither is a bullpen answer yet. Both have minor league options left, Davitt two and Schultz one, which makes them depth the Reds can send to Louisville rather than roster locks.
Arbitration and Non-Tender Candidates
The Reds have 11 arbitration-eligible players left after agreeing with Oswaldo Cabrera on a $1 million deal for 2027 on Oct. 15, which took him off the non-tender list before it was a question. Matt Swartz's MLB Trade Rumors projections put the biggest raises on Elly De La Cruz ($7.9 million), Nick Lodolo and Spencer Steer ($5.7 million each), and Andrew Abbott ($4.5 million). All of them get tendered. Steer is the one worth watching for a trade.
MLBTR listed Graham Ashcraft, Tony Santillan and Matt McLain as non-tender candidates. 80Grade's non-tender model ranks Santillan first among Reds and Brandon Williamson second, with Tejay Antone third, Steer sixth, Ashcraft seventh and McLain 16th. Williamson's ranking makes him a close call, though at $1.3 million with options left he is easy to keep around. McLain's bat was poor this year, a 67 wRC+ in 496 plate appearances, but his glove kept his value near replacement level, so a non-tender is unlikely. What helps him most is that he has never been optioned, so the Reds can send him to Louisville to get right without exposing him to waivers.
My calls: Santillan and JJ Bleday are the cuts. The model is softer on Bleday, 14th, but the reasons below still hold. Both are out of options, Santillan projects at $2.5 million and Bleday at $4.8 million, and neither is a regular. Santillan had a 6.42 ERA in 40 2/3 innings. Antone is the closer call. He had a 3.11 ERA in 55 innings, but he is 33 and in his final arbitration year. I would tender Ashcraft, who still has an option, and McLain for the same reason.
†Arbitration projections by Matt Swartz, MLB Trade Rumors.
DFA Candidates and What an Outright Would Cost
Alex Larson explains the DFA method in DFAs, Outrights and Non-Tenders: How the Roster Rules Actually Work. For the Reds, a few names stand out.
Jose Trevino and Ke'Bryan Hayes have more than five years of service, so neither can be sent to Louisville without his consent, and their guarantees ($5.25 million in 2027 plus a $1 million buyout on his 2028 option for Trevino, more for Hayes through 2029) are owed either way. A catcher who struggled to hit is more likely to be traded or kept as a backup than cut.
Bleday and Santillan, both past three years of service, could refuse an outright. That is why the tender deadline is the cheap place to move on from either one.
Juan Brito and Connor Phillips are both out of options. Brito has under three years of service and no prior outright, so he couldn't refuse one. The risk with him is a waiver claim, not the money.
Rule 5 Protection
The protection deadline is Nov. 17. Likely add: Cam Collier. He is No. 279 in the 80Grade prospect model, the highest-ranked eligible Red, and our grades give him 50 power and a 60 arm with a 40 hit tool. His .654 OPS in 576 Double-A plate appearances is not a protection argument by itself, but he was 21 all year at Chattanooga, and a club picking in December could stash a bat like that.
On the bubble: Carter Graham posted a .902 OPS in 260 Double-A plate appearances. Jay Allen II, unpicked last winter, had an .857 OPS in 377 Triple-A plate appearances. Jose Acuña threw 84 Double-A innings with a 3.54 ERA before a rough Triple-A stretch. Ruben Ibarra (.810 OPS in Double-A) and Johnathan Lavallee (56 strikeouts and 10 walks in 43 1/3 Double-A innings) are worth a look too. Everyone else can be exposed.
40-Man Count Math
The Reds' 40-man stands at 37 after the two claims. Non-tendering Santillan and Bleday would make it 35, and cutting Antone would make it 34. Adding Collier and one bubble name brings it to about 36 or 37.
That leaves three or four spots for a closer, a catcher to replace Stephenson and whatever else the front office can afford, which is a long shopping list for a team that hasn't spent much in free agency lately. Not ideal.
If There's a Lockout
The CBA expires Dec. 1, and a lockout could cancel or postpone the Rule 5 Draft, as the 2021 lockout did to that year's major league phase. Protection decisions are still due before then, so the Nov. 17 list counts either way.