The White Sox Agree to a Three-Year Bet on Dustin May
The White Sox agreed to a three-year, $52.5 million contract with Dustin May, a mid-rotation starter coming off a career-high 145 2/3 innings. The club has not confirmed the deal. The bet is on his stuff and workload after two Tommy John surgeries.
By Gordon Kairis ·
The White Sox agreed Tuesday to a three-year, $52.5 million contract with free-agent right-hander Dustin May, agent Craig Rose confirmed to Jon Heyman of the New York Post. Robert Murray of FanSided was first to report the agreement. A source later confirmed the same terms to ESPN and to MLB.com's Mark Feinsand, who noted that the club has not confirmed the deal. No year-by-year salaries, options or incentives have been reported.
May, 29, gives Chicago a mid-rotation starter coming off a career-high 145 2/3 innings and a World Series with the Brewers. He also has two Tommy John surgeries on his résumé, plus an esophageal tear that wiped out 2024. That is the bet the White Sox are making, a week after general manager Chris Getz called adding starting pitching the club's top priority.

A career high in innings, after two elbow surgeries
May had Tommy John surgery on May 12, 2021, then a second operation on July 18, 2023, when Dr. Neal ElAttrache performed a flexor-tendon repair and a UCL reconstruction revision. Between those two procedures, a lower-back IL stint in 2022 and the long recoveries, he threw 101 innings in the majors from 2021 through 2024. He was already on the 60-day injured list for the elbow in 2024 when, on July 10, he suffered a torn esophagus after food became lodged in his throat and had emergency surgery that night. He missed the entire season.
He came back in 2025 and threw 132 1/3 innings between the Dodgers and Red Sox, with a 4.96 ERA and a 4.88 FIP. After Boston acquired him at the deadline, he went on the 15-day injured list in September with right-elbow neuritis and missed the last 20 regular-season games. In 2026 he made all 31 of his starts, did not go on the injured list and set a career high in innings.
Two seasons of 130-plus innings is real progress. It is not the same as becoming a 180-inning workhorse, and it does not erase the file.
Two versions of 2026, and the stuff
The Cardinals half of last season is the argument for the deal. May went 5-7 with a 4.38 ERA and a 3.15 FIP in 109 innings over 21 starts, with 2.6 FanGraphs WAR and 0.6 Baseball-Reference WAR, and he threw a complete-game shutout. Milwaukee acquired him at the Aug. 3 deadline and got a different pitcher: a 5.65 ERA and 5.06 FIP in 36 2/3 innings over 10 starts, with 0.1 FanGraphs WAR and minus-0.3 Baseball-Reference WAR. He gave up seven home runs in that stretch. In the postseason he made two starts and three relief appearances, posting a 5.73 ERA in 11 innings, with a 3.37 FIP in a small sample, as the Brewers won the World Series.
For the full season he was 7-9 with a 4.70 ERA, a 3.63 FIP and 144 strikeouts in 145 2/3 innings. FanGraphs has him at 2.8 WAR; Baseball-Reference has him at 0.4. The gap is the difference between FIP-based value and runs allowed, and it is the same split that shows up in his career line, 7.0 FanGraphs WAR and 2.9 Baseball-Reference WAR in 469 2/3 innings.
The stuff is why Chicago is willing to live with that uncertainty. Baseball Savant had his four-seamer at 96.9 mph and his sinker at 96.6 in 2026, both up more than a mile an hour from 2025. He is no longer a sweeper-first pitcher. Sweeper usage was cut nearly in half, from 39.3 percent to 17.7 percent, and the four-seamer (24.8 percent) and cutter (23.7 percent, 93.3 mph) became his two most-used pitches. The curveball returned at 7.6 percent, and a changeup he barely threw in 2025 was up to 6.1 percent. The cutter was his best pitch by run value. The sweeper still missed bats, at a 27.7 percent whiff rate, but was a net negative.
A mid-rotation add, not a new ace
May should not be read as the new No. 2 starter. Sean Burke led the 2026 staff with 172 1/3 innings and a 3.34 ERA, and he is a rotation lock. Getz has already moved Grant Taylor from the bullpen into the rotation and called him a "top-of-the-rotation-type arm," per MLB.com's Scott Merkin. Taylor threw 84 innings with a 2.25 ERA in relief last year; the four games listed as starts were openers.
That leaves May as a three-year mid-rotation piece in a group that also includes Anthony Kay, Davis Martin and Luis Castillo. Castillo, acquired from Seattle at the deadline, put up an 8.42 ERA in 31 innings with the White Sox, finished the year on the injured list with a shoulder issue and is due $22.75 million in 2027. May does not solve that by himself.
Chicago needed the innings. White Sox starters ranked last in the majors with 674 2/3 innings last season, 26th with a 4.60 ERA, and the club leaned on openers and bullpen games in the regular season and the playoffs. Burke was the only starter the White Sox truly employed across their seven postseason games. May has already worked as a starter and a reliever in October, so a hybrid role would not be new if Chicago goes that way again.
What three years says about the timeline
The White Sox went 84-78 last season, finished second in the American League Central and reached the postseason for the first time since 2021, after 100-loss seasons in 2023, 2024 and 2025. They beat Houston in a two-game Wild Card Series and lost to Cleveland in five games in the Division Series. A three-year guarantee that runs through 2029 is a bet that 2026 was the start of something, not a one-year bump.
Getz previewed this kind of addition a week ago. "We're going to exhaust the starter market, both free agency — we'll take a look — along with trades," he said on MLB Network Radio, per MLB Trade Rumors. "That is our top priority." He also told reporters the club is "targeting individuals who could pitch in the middle to the top of the rotation," and that "it's not always at the top of the market."
May, a 29-year-old with remaining stuff and a medical file that still follows him, fits that description. Whether the White Sox are done adding starters is a separate question. The first one, the one they agreed to Tuesday, still has to become official.