Two Gold Gloves, One Arm, and a Statcast Shrug

By ·

On Thursday we looked at three American League Gold Glove finalists whose defensive numbers seemed to describe different players: Taylor Walls at shortstop, Cole Young at second base and Chandler Simpson in left field. The awards came out Sunday night, Nov. 1, on ESPN. Walls and Young won. Simpson did not, and the left field award went to Cody Bellinger. That is two wins for the metric a coaching staff reads most easily, and one for the metric that combines range with an arm.

Our earlier piece, Three Gold Glove Finalists, Two Sets of Numbers, laid out why the systems split. This one checks how the results lined up with them.

How the Vote Works

Rawlings' announcement repeats the structure: each team's manager and up to six coaches vote within their own league and cannot vote for their own players, and the SABR Defensive Index makes up about 25 percent of the total. MLB.com describes the split as 75 percent managers and coaches, 25 percent sabermetrics. The index feeds in, but the majority of every ballot comes from a dugout.

Taylor Walls, the First Rays Shortstop to Win

Walls beat Bobby Witt Jr., who had won the last two AL awards at shortstop, and Andrés Giménez. MLB.com's winners story says he led all shortstops with 21 Defensive Runs Saved and is the first Rays shortstop to win a Gold Glove. The club's most recent winner at any position was Kevin Kiermaier in center field in 2019.

Baseball Savant's live leaderboard, checked Monday evening, has Walls at -3 Outs Above Average, tied for 32nd of 42 qualified shortstops. On Thursday that number was -4. Witt is at +24 and Giménez at +19. Walls's Fielding Run Value is -1.9. The breakdown hasn't moved: -5 on balls in front of him, zero on balls to either side and +1 going back. He converted 81 percent of his chances against an expected 82.

So the voters sided with DRS over Statcast. On Walls, DRS had him leading his position and OAA had him in the bottom quarter, and the managers and coaches went with the system that credits positioning and sure hands. Witt's +24 OAA was the best of any shortstop on Savant's page. That wasn't enough.

Cole Young and the Ballot Statistics

Young's case was built for a dugout ballot, and it won. MLB.com's winners story says he led all AL second basemen with 16 DRS. The Mariners' finalist release had him leading AL second basemen in games (157), innings (1,350 1/3), putouts (223), assists (397) and fielding percentage (.990). He is the first Mariners winner at second base since Bret Boone won three straight from 2002 to 2004, in his second big league season.

Savant still has him at -5 OAA, tied for 35th of 42 qualified second basemen, with an FRV of -4.7. The directional split is the same as on Thursday: -7 on balls to his right, toward the middle of the diamond, +2 to his left, zero in front and -1 going back. His 79 percent conversion rate matches the expected 79 percent exactly.

The two finalists he beat both graded well on Savant. Michael Massey is at +11 OAA and +7.2 FRV. Chase Meidroth is at +8 OAA and +10.9 FRV, the best FRV of any AL second baseman on the page. Young's case was the one a manager could recite from the media guide: always in the lineup, almost never an error. The ground balls up the middle that got past him don't show up in fielding percentage, and the vote didn't seem to count them either.

Chandler Simpson and the Arm

Simpson was the finalist the tracking data liked best, and he's the one who lost. Savant has him at +9 OAA, first among 33 qualified left fielders, ahead of Jackson Chourio (+7) and Bellinger (+6). He was +5 on balls in front of him, +3 and +2 to either side, and -1 going back. A year earlier he was at -5 OAA, mostly in center field.

His FRV is +2.9, and the arm explains it: about +7.3 runs for range, with -4.4 runs for throwing taken back out. Bellinger's FRV is +8.2, with +5.2 for range and +2.9 for his arm. MLB.com's winners story credits Bellinger with 21 DRS, tied for third in the majors, and eight assists, and says his average arm strength rose to 93.3 mph, the 94th percentile.

This is where the systems agreed. DRS and FRV both had Bellinger ahead of Simpson, and both charge for the throw. OAA was the only one of the three that put Simpson first, because it counts range and not much else in left field. Bellinger won his second Gold Glove, after taking one in right field with the Dodgers in 2019.

The Rest of the American League

The other AL winners mostly led at least one of the systems.

Dillon Dingler, Tigers catcher: MLB.com says he led all catchers in FRV (17) and DRS (15). Savant's page has him at 16.6 FRV.

Ceddanne Rafaela, Red Sox center fielder: MLB.com says he was second among outfielders in OAA (16) and tied for third in DRS (21). His FRV on Savant is 16.0.

Wilyer Abreu, Red Sox right fielder: MLB.com says he led all players with 28 DRS and had 13 assists. His Savant FRV is a more modest 5.3, which puts him alongside Walls and Young among the AL winners with the widest gaps between the systems.

Caleb Durbin, Red Sox third baseman: 13 DRS, best among AL third basemen per MLB.com, and 6.4 FRV on Savant.

Christian Walker, Astros first baseman: MLB.com says he tied for the AL lead at first base in FRV with 7. Savant has him at 6.7. It's his fourth Gold Glove.

Tanner Bibee won for pitchers and Ezequiel Duran for utility. MLB.com says Duran had a combined 17 OAA across positions.

What the Results Say About the Voters

In all three of Thursday's races, the winner was the finalist with the best DRS. Baseball-Reference, which carries the Sports Info Solutions figures, has Witt at 8 and Giménez at 2, Massey at 5 and Meidroth at 0, and Simpson at 8. In two of them, Walls and Young, that meant going against Statcast by a wide margin. In the third, DRS and FRV agreed, and OAA was the one left out.

Our earlier piece ended by saying the three systems would still disagree on Monday morning. They do. Savant still has Walls tied for 32nd and Young tied for 35th at their positions. Those are the same rankings that read as below average on Thursday, and they're now attached to two Gold Gloves. Nobody changed the numbers. The ballots just put more weight on a different set of them.

The Platinum Glove fan vote is open on Rawlings.com through Thursday, Nov. 5, and the winners will be announced at the ceremony in New York on Friday, Nov. 6.

Read the full story on 80Grade